Insurer Scorecard.

Florida property insurer · NAIC 10835

Castle Key Indemnity Company

Claims-dispute record from the Florida DFS Intent-to-Litigate portal, July 2021 through 2026-10-24.

4,645
notices since July 2021
523
in the last 12 months
#16
of 182 Florida insurers by notices
1.6%
share of all Florida notices
179,112
policies in force (2026-07 quarter, FLOIR)
2.9
notices per 1,000 policies, last 12 months

Monthly new notices

Over the last 12 data months (Nov 2025 to Oct 2026), 523 notices were filed against Castle Key Indemnity Company, compared with 887 in the 12 months before that (-41%).

Last 12 data months
MonthNew noticesCumulative
Nov 2025414,163
Dec 2025554,218
Jan 2026574,275
Feb 2026444,319
Mar 2026594,378
Apr 2026524,430
May 2026464,476
Jun 2026294,505
Jul 2026414,546
Aug 2026394,585
Sep 2026324,617
Oct 2026284,645

How to read this

A notice of intent to initiate litigation is the pre-suit notice a Florida policyholder must file with the Department of Financial Services under §627.70152 before suing a property insurer. It records that a claim dispute reached that stage; it is not a finding of wrongdoing, and it does not show how the dispute was resolved. Raw counts rise with insurer size, so compare carriers on the per-1,000-policies figure where one is shown, and see the methodology for inclusion rules, classification and limitations. Withdrawn notices are excluded.

Compare Castle Key Indemnity Company with other insurers, by county and damage type →